All managers are not leaders but all leaders are managers - By Ajay Bhat

Conceptually Management & leadership are two different sides of the same coin. All executives are managers, in fact all employees may classified as managers for the assigned task & responsibility but in essence only the executives working in top positions are genuinely defined as the, management of the company. Among the top management the Leaders by implication are the people with vision, deep understanding of business, acumen, drive, ability to lead & guide people, risk taking ability etc.

All managers are not leaders but all leaders are managers.

Tens & hundreds of books have been written on leadership, management institutions from ivy leagues to well-known business schools teach leadership. Therefore it’s a much discussed & debated subject. The question is, Do we get leaders from ivy leagues & business schools? or humming books on leadership. The answer is clearly big NO.
In my experience of corporate sector essentially Group CFO 0f Monnet & after watching companies of all sizes & reputations, I dwelt upon this subject & realized that there are basic fundamental characteristics which make genuine leaders or so to say senior corporate managers assigned with leadership roles. These fundamental characteristics may be classified as;
  1. Academic & Professional Background
  2. Job Experience
  3. Knowledge
  4. Attitude
  5. Approach

Academic & Professional Background

Basic academic qualifications in a relevant or related subject provide fertility & understanding. It’s futile to write about qualifications as the whole edifice of society is based on education. However the quality of academics does matter, students from top schools & colleges do well relative to their counterparts from average institutions, however the same is never a guarantee for students from top bracket institution for success in corporate ladders & or we cant conclude average success of students from lower rung institutions. In fact many of the successful leaders do not have any Ivy League/top bracket institution tag. Therefore qualification and quality of academic institution does matter but may be a means but not the end of it. Students from average institutions have also achieved wonderful feats in careers and in fact have better hunger and fire to do well in conjunction with other characteristics discussed hereinafter. In the modern economic environment, academic qualifications have assumed far greater importance compared to its relevance in the past. To conclude a desirable academic or professional qualification is a pre-requisite for a successful corporate leader given the challenges of global integrated economy & increased play of technology.

Job Experience

Experience is an essential ingredient for a corporate leader. Practical Experience exposes a potential leader to intricate nuisances of job & corporate working. The quality & content of experience isn’t what job offers you but on inquisitiveness of the person. Experience isn’t also related only to the company of association but the engagement of mind with internal & external environment. You learn less from what you handle but you learn more from what you don’t handle. The quality of experience does vary from company to company. Experience in a company strong in system and process and in a structured & professional working environment is superior, knowledgeable and valuable. Job experience and company are complimentary to each other. A job experience in a less descript company may not offer a desirable experience profile. Job experience is always evaluated and correlated with a company of repute and known professionalism and is rightly so. To a right individual, experience is a curtain between unseen & eagerness to see, main reason about holistic involvement of some compared to their colleagues & friends. Right experience reflects in the performance, ability & delivery. Experience is a pedestal of growth & recognition. Experience is all about life, personal, impersonal, formal, informal. It’s exhaustive but not inclusive. It’s neither a debate nor a discussion, its real & just real EXPERIENCE.

Knowledge

Knowledge is an ocean where all rivers of academic qualification, general reading of books & journals, learning from experience on the job, learning from what has been happening around you in the industry, country & even globally. Knowledge shared by juniors, peers, seniors, colleagues & by experts & knowledge available in print & social media. Knowledge has no definition in my opinion, it’s an unending debate.
However knowledge in the context of corporate leader may be summed up as broader & deeper understanding of the role earned by academic background, experience & clarity & understanding of intricacy of the subject. Knowledge is essential to perform a leadership role, it inspires & motivates the people being led. It generates respect, recognition & following. Knowledgeable person is looked by all for guidance, support & direction and hence become a natural leader eventually. Knowledge is more relevant about profile of role & responsibility rather than generic issues. In a dynamic global environment, knowledge transcends opportunities & challenges. Knowledge for a business leader is a 360 view of core, fundamental issues of operational & strategic matters to create a vision & mission. ...read complete here

Location: India

Popular posts from this blog

Off Manifestos & ….. Mandates (By Ajay Bhat Monnet Ispat)

A ritual of issuing manifestos precedes democratic process in India to elect State & Central Governments. Manifestos otherwise are important piece of declaration about the agenda of political parties they propose to fulfill if voted to power. That we all know, but the promises made mainly by mainstream political parties have become longer in content & louder in commitment beyond the comprehension of average citizen of this country. Except key issues that concern broader population, I don’t assume an average citizen has the eagerness to read or unrelenting faith on wish list of manifestos. The key political parties also detail the plan outlay of expenditure on various heads like health care, education, infrastructure etc and if one were to add up the maths of these numbers, any one would wonder the veracity of such exorbitant claims & essentially the resources needed to accomplish them. Tall promises and big numbers have rendered these documents non-interesting subjects
Read more

Promoter Leadership vs. Professional Leadership - Ajay Bhat Monnet Ispat

Last few years have been predominantly thickly overcast with problems of non-performing assets in the banking system. It’s not that the NPA is a new development or has been a fresh news, NPA’s are synonymous with lending business globally so are they in India as well but the magnitude & size of NPA’s in India after 2010 has been rising at alarming rate. The objective of my article is not to discuss the NPA problem as such but one of the essential causes why they happen. Lot has been written on this subject but among the various reasons yet hidden there is one important & critical reason, which is not debated & at least has not been cited as one of the key inputs of this NPA menace. Let me try to elucidate this, let’s look at top 50 companies referred to IBC in the past over 18 months. We know clearly they are all over leveraged & their business models have failed to meet the obligations, hence the reference. Why are these companies over-leveraged & why did the
Read more